“30%” is a term often used here at FreshAddress. But please don’t get all that excited! Not yet anyway! We don’t mean “30% off,” “30% savings” or even “30% more.” We wish we were able to offer better news when it comes to the percentage, “30%,” but unfortunately, it refers to a problem every marketer must grapple with: email list churn.

That’s right. According to industry research and estimates, you can expect 30% or more of your email addresses to bounce or become inactive every year.

They Love Me. They Really Love Me!

“But my customers and donors love what we do,” you say. “Why would they leave me without giving me their forwarding addresses?” It’s a simple answer really. People move, take new jobs, graduate or change schools, switch ISPs, and change email providers all of the time. Perhaps the Verizon bundle is just too good to pass up. Or perhaps, as web-based email providers go, users jump from Yahoo to Hotmail or over to Gmail or back again.

I Have A Dream

How great would it be if everybody called in or updated each and every one of their online relationships saying, “Please note that I have switched email addresses and my new email address is XXXXX.” I am sure this dream of mine would make a lot of you sleep better at night.

But my dream is still just a dream Email list churn is very real indeed!  As a result, emails start dropping off, bounce rates start to increase, your deliverability rates fall, your reputation with ISPs and perhaps your ESP (if you use an ESP) begins to diminish, and overall performance and revenues decrease.

I bet some of you are thinking “My email system removes our bounces, leaving me with the customers and donors who really care about us.” If only it were that easy. Unfortunately, people these days are way too busy to notify much more than their closest friends when they change their email addresses. And as many marketers and organizations have experienced, re-engaging with lost or inactive customers can result in higher open rates, click-through rates, and revenues than you’ve been generating from your somewhat tired workhorse of a house file.

How to Minimize Email List Churn

Unsubscribing, or opting out, is an inescapable aspect of email-marketing life, but it doesn’t have to be an inevitable one. Below are strategies you can use to reduce the number of subscribers who are heading to the exits.

The changes we suggest can not only help you trim your unsubscribe list, but also help you build a stronger email program. One that’s less susceptible to spam complaints and inactivity, two other leading contributors to email list churn.

1. Never buy email lists.

Buying addresses is a common practice in direct mail, but it can be a fatal mistake in email. Most people guard their inboxes more carefully than their mailboxes. Purchased lists have three big problems because you have no:

  1. Business connection to those address owners.
  2. Guarantees that the address owners gave their permission to be on those lists.
  3. Assurance that the listed addresses are valid.

Save your money for less dicey acquisition efforts.

2.  Use a clear and transparent opt-in.

Voluntary subscribers are your best assets. Do you make email subscription a required condition for doing business with your company – such as opening an account, buying something, entering a contest, or contacting customer support? If so, state that up front and in plain language when you ask for the email address.

Don’t load your opt-in form with a pre-checked consent box, either. Instead of driving subscribers into your program like cattle into a pen, attract them with a succinct explanation of the benefit they’ll get by joining up.

3. Contact new subscribers ASAP.

“Out of sight, out of mind” applies to email, too. Send your first message immediately after opt-in, especially if you email weekly or less often. That first email is all-important. Instead of dropping your newbies right into your regular broadcast stream, send a welcome message that offers information like this:

  • Why they’re getting your emails (crucial if you require opt-in for doing business with you)
  • What kinds of messages you send and how often (include a screenshot of a sample email or link to your newsletter archive)
  • How to manage their subscriptions to make their emails more relevant (link to a preference center)
  • Directions on unsubscribing (to avoid clicking the “report spam” if they change their minds or subscribed by accident)
4. Mix up your messages.

Email is famous for driving sales at low cost, but it’s also a superb tool to keep your brand in front of your customers when they aren’t in the market to buy. Along with your “20% off” promos, add a few that tell a story about your products or company, explain how to buy or use them correctly, or ask their opinion about your products, your service, or your company.

5. Track open and click rates for new subscribers to detect early warning signs of inactivity. 

Watch for new subscribers who don’t act on your messages in the first two to three weeks after opt-in. Target them with an email asking about potential problems or tempt them with a special offer or survey.

6. Offer alternatives to unsubscribing, such as “opting down” or switching to another channel. 

Yes, you must move an unsubscribed address out of your active database upon request. But, not everybody who clicks your unsub link really wants to leave. Send them to a preference page that lists options along with a confirmation of the unsub request:

  • Choose a lower frequency
  • Opt out from some but not all communications
  • Update an email address
  • Opt in to communications in another channel, such as direct mail or texts
7. Use ECOA (Email Change of Address) to reconnect with lapsed subscribers & offset email list churn

Your subscribers are changing, updating and abandoning their email addresses constantly, whether they’re changing names, switching providers, or moving to new employers. Sometimes they remember to update their addresses with their most favored email senders, but more often they don’t.

FreshAddress’ patented ECOA service checks your inactive addresses against our proprietary database of change-pairs and contacts the new address holders on your behalf with an invitation to update their data.

Recent Posts

As you put your 2022 marketing plans together, you’ll concentrate on acquisition, budget and campaigns. We would like to add another item to your list and move it to the No. 1 priority: Your data! Why data? Because data is the lifeblood of your marketing program. Without fresh, accurate and useful data, you can’t market […]

We want to wish all of our FreshPerspectives readers a happy, healthy, and prosperous 2022! As we close out 2021, it’s a great opportunity to set priorities for the coming twelve months. Whether you’re new to email marketing or an industry veteran, consider these New Year’s Resolutions to help ring in a banner year in […]

In my holiday letter a year ago, I hoped that in 2021 we’d be seeing each other in the office and at trade shows. That has not yet come to pass, so I am especially grateful for the significant milestones our company has achieved this year: TowerData received a strategic investment from TZP Group, a […]
Chat with us