Did your last email win-back campaign miss the mark?

If so, do you know why? Let’s take a look at the likely culprit and how to get you moving in the right direction.

You’re Emailing Ghosts!

Based on our work at FreshAddress with hundreds of leading marketers, we’ve found that the leading factor resulting in inactive (“ghosted”) subscribers is simply that you’re emailing them at email accounts they no longer read.

  • Approximately 30% of an email list goes stale on an annual basis;
  • BUT most customers/donors don’t update their accounts with their preferred stores or nonprofits when they change their email addresses.

Accordingly, the biggest problem with most win-back campaigns is that companies develop interesting programs with attractive promotions – yes, money does talk – but then email their campaign to old, dead addresses.

Move Your Email Win-Back Campaigns From Zero to Hero

Email Prospecting Hero
Want to shift the odds in your favor and win back some lost sheep? Here are 5 tips to get you moving in the right direction. 

Tip #1: Don’t Delete Inactive Addresses

To ensure you’re not wasting your money on win-back programs that generate minimal returns, a successful win-back strategy needs to incorporate an Email Change of Address (ECOA) service to ensure that the creative and offers you’re sending are reaching people at their preferred email addresses, rather than simply falling on deaf ears.

Tip #2:  Ensure any list you or your service provider is sending to is SafeToSend®

It has to be deliverable and free of toxic addresses like:

  • Spamtraps & Honeypots;
  • Heavy spam complainers; and
  • Role accounts.

Tip #3: Make sure your win-back offer is attractive and aggressive

You might only get one more bite at the apple so make it good. Here’s a great example:

Northern Brewer - Win Back Email Example

Tip #4: Perform A/B testing on your subject lines

Combine this with real-time multivariate testing of the different levers in your creative. This is a surefire recipe to maximize your open and click-through rates.

Tip #5: Know your goals up front

 Perform the analytics after each win-back campaign and use the results to optimize future campaigns.

Win-Back Campaigns are Difficult, Not Impossible. 

Getting your customers to fall in love with you all over again isn’t easy. Neither is winning the Presidency but a new President gets elected every 4 years.

 

Related Articles:

 

list churn banner1

About the Author

Keith Reinhardt Marketing Manager
As our Marketing Manager, Keith offers an abundance of knowledge in all things marketing.  His primary duties include planning and implementing product and corporate marketing strategies, collaborating with our sales and product teams to develop new marketing tactics, public relations, and managing the creative process for our newsletter, webinars, case studies, and more.  Keith is also a master of content creation and has written over 100 press releases!

Become a Better Email Marketer Sign up to get our expert tips delivered to your inbox.

Recent Posts

To be successful, political campaigns need to get their message out to as many voters as possible. Email plays a crucial role in this process. It allows your campaign to connect with people that want to hear from you, any time you want, with whatever message you like. Here’s the rub. Email only works if […]
Email Design Tips

Ready to get back to work now that your holiday email campaigns are the rear view mirror? Yeah, neither are we. So, let’s look at some of the share worthy emails that landed in our inboxes since the season began back in, oh, about August. In case anybody’s watching you, just say you’re doing research […]
Email Marketing Tips

(Updated in November 2019) We did it so you don’t have to: One of our staff members saved every single holiday-themed email subject line she received in both personal and business email accounts to look for creativity and trends in the shopping season. Why subject lines and not the email messages themselves? Mainly because this […]
Chat with us